玉屏风治什么病最好| 毒血症是什么病| 小心眼是什么意思| 鬼一般找什么人压床| 骨转移是什么意思| 舌边有齿痕是什么原因| bpa是什么材料| 樟脑是什么东西| 戴黄金对身体有什么好处| 芹菜可以炒什么| 打破伤风挂什么科| 仲夏夜是什么时候| 喝完酒胃疼吃什么药| 环切是什么意思| 心肌标志物是查什么的| 醉酒第二天吃什么才能缓解难受| 农历11月14日是什么星座| 赤脚医生是什么意思| acei是什么意思| 梦见吃蜂蜜是什么预兆| 跳蚤怕什么| 考试穿什么颜色最吉利| 七月上旬是什么时候| 皮肤病吃什么药最好| 无所不用其极是什么意思| 俯卧撑有什么好处| 气血不足补什么| 阳历6月21日是什么星座| rf医学上是什么意思| 0a是什么意思| 胆囊壁毛糙吃什么药效果好| 蜕变是什么意思| 阳虚吃什么调理| ovs是什么品牌| 为什么做b超要憋尿| 2021属什么生肖| 血脂高会导致什么后果| 排尿带血是什么原因| 老烂腿用什么药最好| 下焦湿热吃什么中成药| 胃部检查除了胃镜还有什么方法| 芋头什么时候种植最好| 中耳炎吃什么| 心肌缺血吃什么补得快| 王姓为什么出不了皇帝| 什么是sp| 甲状腺是什么| 大便粗大是什么原因| 甲状腺tsh高说明什么| 卤水点豆腐的卤水是什么| 老子是什么时期的人| 92年的猴是什么命| 中山大学是什么级别| 职业测试你适合什么工作| 尿道感染是什么原因引起| 肉偿是什么意思| 李子是什么颜色| 为什么庙里不让孕妇去| 12月8号什么星座| 阴茎插入阴道什么感觉| 匀字五行属什么| 宫颈纳囊用什么药治疗效果好| 八府巡按是什么官| 囊胚和冻胚有什么区别| 菩提子手串有什么好处| 嘴巴周围长痘痘是什么原因引起的| 大拇指麻木是什么原因| quake是什么意思| 什么是滑脉| 乙肝表面抗原是什么意思| 朝鲜面是什么原料做的| 肝肾阴虚吃什么药| 子宫占位是什么意思| 英国为什么要脱欧| 隐士是什么意思| 心率低吃什么药好| 钾血症是什么病| 钻牛角尖是什么意思| 舌苔白吃什么药效果好| 艾司唑仑是什么药| 美妙绝伦是什么意思| 倒立有什么好处| 吃葵花籽有什么好处和坏处吗| 荷花和睡莲有什么区别| 颈椎头晕吃点什么药| 规格是指什么| 十月十三是什么星座| 头昏吃什么药效果最好| 卵巢早衰是什么引起的| 夭折是什么意思| 保险凭证号是什么| 10000mah是什么意思| 欧珑香水什么档次| 暗渡陈仓什么意思| 无痛肠镜和普通肠镜有什么区别| 摘胆对身体有什么影响| 被蜱虫咬了挂什么科| 二十不惑什么意思| 医学pr是什么意思| 喉咙发炎吃什么食物好| 异常出汗是什么原因| 刑事拘留意味着什么| 标准员是干什么的| 榴莲什么季节吃最好| 过期的酸奶有什么用| 渐冻症是什么| 风雨雷电代表什么生肖| 嘴唇发红是什么原因| 什么是癔症病| 什么值得买官网| 川流不息什么意思| 左卵巢囊性结构是什么意思| 为什么挠脚心会痒| 糖尿病吃什么| 副巡视员是什么级别| 西瓜跟什么不能一起吃| 永五行属什么| 人加一笔变成什么字| 药学专业是干什么的| 不小心怀孕了吃什么药可以流掉| 肺炎是什么| 好运是什么生肖| 碧玺是什么材质| 人生最重要的是什么| 朗格手表什么档次| 产后第一次来月经是什么颜色| gag是什么意思| 女人梦见猪是什么预兆| 高危型hpv有什么症状| 为什么刚小便完又有尿意| 美尼尔眩晕症吃什么药| 尖嘴猴腮是什么生肖| 改善记忆力吃什么药好| 前列腺不能吃什么食物| 蛋白粉什么时候吃最好| 什么样的人容易得结石| 人心叵测什么意思| 静脉曲张用什么药好| 打嗝不停是什么原因| 轮状胎盘是什么意思| 锌是补什么的| 蝙蝠来家里是什么预兆| 什么是音调| 姿态是什么意思| 热玛吉是什么意思| 1996年什么命| 脖子淋巴结发炎吃什么药| 白玫瑰花语是什么| 散佚是什么意思| 空明什么意思| 0点是什么时辰| 中耳炎用什么药| 什么叫前列腺钙化| 禾加末念什么| 什么药治痒效果最好| 女人吃什么排卵最快| 甘胆酸偏高是什么原因| 东南五行属什么| 天高云淡是什么季节| 为什么叫白俄罗斯| 补铁有什么作用和功效| 麦芒是什么意思| 丹参是什么样子| 3个火读什么| 什么是中药| bp什么意思| 戊五行属什么| 4.12是什么星座| 什么是特殊膳食| 双重否定句是什么意思| 龙跟什么生肖配对最好| 肾构错瘤要注意什么| 大豆油是什么豆做的| 乳腺3类是什么意思| 胃不舒服吃什么食物好| ldl是什么意思| 萎缩性胃炎吃什么中成药| 圣经是什么时候写的| 什么发型好看| 母鸡是什么意思| 血脂高吃什么水果最好| 富不过三代是什么意思| 菌群失调是什么意思| 气短是什么原因引起的| 勇者胜的上半句是什么| 红细胞偏高是什么病| 下象棋有什么好处| 健康是什么| 迷茫是什么意思| 虾仁炒什么菜好吃| 肠梗阻是什么病| 左手麻木是什么原因引起的| 口臭是什么病| 黑户什么意思| 耳鸣是什么感觉| 每天喝柠檬水有什么好处| 晚睡早起是什么原因| 尽兴是什么意思| 矢的意思是什么| 什么是兼职| 黄金豆是什么豆| 什么是渡劫| 心阳虚吃什么中成药| 胰腺饱满是什么意思| 感染幽门螺杆菌吃什么药| 茹毛饮血什么意思| 牙疼是什么原因引起的| 蚕屎有什么作用和功效| 扁导体发炎吃什么药| 2222是什么意思| 男生叫你姑娘什么意思| 甘油三酯高是什么原因引起的| 什么什么望外| 六字箴言是什么意思| 月经期间适合吃什么水果| 转头头晕是什么原因| 导乐是什么意思| 男性夜间盗汗什么原因| 什么是比例| 脂肪有什么作用| 养胃吃什么水果| 心静自然凉是什么意思| 肩袖损伤吃什么药效果最好| 康复治疗技术学什么| 尚清是什么意思| 金牛座和什么星座最配| 痰湿体质吃什么中成药| 为什么不能天天喝豆浆| 左行气右行血什么意思| 嘴里发咸是什么原因| 7月1日是什么节| 四大皆空是什么生肖| 狗脚朕什么意思| 黄油是什么意思| 贼眉鼠眼是什么生肖| 血液病是什么病| 水瓶座女生和什么星座男生最配| 过敏源挂什么科| 打牛是什么意思| 钟爱一生是什么意思| 咳嗽吃什么食物好得最快最有效| 石头五行属什么| 包皮溃烂用什么药| 副乳挂什么科| 小燕子的尾巴像什么| tt什么意思| 怀孕是什么意思| 变化无穷是什么生肖| 窦骁父母是干什么的| 急性会厌炎吃什么药| 鸡犬不宁是什么生肖| cems是什么意思| 弊病是什么意思| 吃过敏药有什么副作用| 爸爸的爸爸叫什么儿歌| 耳鸣吃什么药效果最好| 误食干燥剂有什么危害| 四季常青财运旺是什么生肖| col是什么的缩写| 检查肾功能挂什么科| 党员有什么好处| 松子吃了有什么好处和坏处| 哈欠是什么意思| lge是什么意思| 百度
A woman shows police officers her apartment in Kyiv after it was damaged by a Russian drone strike, on Wednesday.—Reuters
A woman shows police officers her apartment in Kyiv after it was damaged by a Russian drone strike, on Wednesday.—Reuters

KHARKIV: “It barely exists anymore,” said the mayor of Vovchansk, an industrial town razed by a Russian onslaught shocking even for the killing fields of eastern Ukraine.

Vovchansk has no great history but its geography could not be more tragic. Just five kilometres from the Russian border, drone footage from the Ukrainian military this summer shows a lunar landscape of ruins stretching for miles. And it has got worse since.

“Ninety percent of the centre is flattened,” said mayor Tamaz Gambarashvili, a towering man in uniform, who runs what is left of Vovchansk from the regional capital of Kharkiv, an hour and a half’s drive away. “The enemy continues its massive shelling,” he added.

Six out of 10 of Vovchansk’s buildings have been totally destroyed, with 18 percent partially ruined, according to analysis of satellite images by the independent open-source intelligence collective Bellingcat. But the destruction is much worse in the city centre, which has been levelled north of the Vovcha River. Journalists in Kyiv, Kharkiv and Paris worked with Bellingcat to tell how, building by building, an entire city was wiped off the map in just a few weeks — and to show the human toll it has taken.

The sheer pace of the destruction dwarfed that of even Bakhmut, the “meatgrinder” Donbas region city where some of the most brutal killing of the war has been done, a Ukrainian officer who fought in both cities said. “I was in Bakhmut, so I know how the battles unfolded there,” Lieutenant Denys Yaroslavsky insisted. “What took two or three months in Bakhmut happened in just two or three weeks in Vovchansk.”

Invaded, then freed

Vovchansk had a population of about 20,000 before the war. It now lives only in the memories of the survivors who managed to flee. Beyond its factories, the city had a “medical school, a technical college, seven schools and numerous kindergartens,” Nelia Stryzhakova, the head of its library, said in Kharkiv.

It even had a workshop that made “carriages for period films. We were even interesting, in our own way,” insisted Stryzhakova, 61. Add to that a regional hospital, rebuilt in 2017 with nearly 10 million euros ($10.8 million) of German aid, a church packed for religious feasts, and a vast hydraulic machinery plant. Once the town’s economic lifeblood, its ruins are now being fought over by both armies.

Vovchansk was quickly occupied by the Russian army after it invaded Ukraine in February 2022, but was then retaken by Kyiv in a lightning counter attack that autumn.

Despite enduring regular Russian bombardment, it was relatively calm. Then something very different happened on May 10.

Badly defended

Exhausted after weeks of hard fighting 100 kilometres to the south, the Ukrainian 57th Brigade was regrouping near Vovchansk when one of its reconnaissance units noticed something strange.

“We spotted two Russian armoured troop carriers that had just crossed the border,” recalled Lieutenant Yaroslavsky, who was leading the unit. They were the advance guard of one of the most intense Russian offensives since the beginning of the war, with Moscow throwing several thousand soldiers at the city.

“There were no fortifications, no mines” to slow down their advance, Yaroslavsky said, still furious at the “negligence or corruption” that allowed this to happen.

Some “17,000 people lost their homes. Why? Because someone didn’t build fortifications,” fumed the 42-year-old officer. “We control the city today, but what we control is a pile of rubble,” he added bitterly.

President Volodymyr Zelensky cancelled an overseas trip to rush to Kharkiv, admitting that the Russian army had pushed between five and 10 kilometres into Ukraine. The people of Vovchansk, meanwhile, were living a nightmare.

‘Drones like mosquitoes’

“The Russians started bombing,” said Galyna Zharova, who lived at 16A Stepova Street -- an apartment building now reduced to ruins, as images analysed by Bellingcat and confirmed.

“We were right on the front line. No one could come and get us out,” added the 50-year-old, who now lives with her family in a university dormitory in Kharkiv.

“We went down to the cellar. All the buildings were burning. We were crammed into basements (for nearly four weeks) until June 3,” her husband Viktor, 65, added.

Eventually, the couple decided to flee on foot. “Drones were flying around us like wasps, like mosquitoes,” Galyna remembered. They walked for several kilometres before being rescued by Ukrainian volunteers.

“The city was beautiful. The people were beautiful. We had everything,” sighed librarian Stryzhakova. “No one could have imagined that in just five days, we would be wiped off the face of the Earth.” The 125,000 books in the library she had run at 8 Tokhova Street went up in smoke. More than half of the families in eastern Ukraine have relatives in Russia.

Published in Dawn, October 31st, 2024

Opinion

Editorial

Hybrid ruin
Updated 03 Aug, 2025

Hybrid ruin

The PTI may be suffering, but it still wants the blessing of its tormentors more than the sympathy of their other victims.
No advantage
03 Aug, 2025

No advantage

THE new agreement between Pakistan and the US, heralded as a ‘strategic’ breakthrough in their trade and...
Starvation politics
03 Aug, 2025

Starvation politics

THE visit of US envoy Steve Witkoff to Gaza’s aid corridors underlines how broken the West’s humanitarian...
TTP footholds
Updated 02 Aug, 2025

TTP footholds

While terrorism issue must be taken up with Afghanistan, local responses should ensure thorough CT actions so KP doesn't suffer endlessly.
USC’s closure
02 Aug, 2025

USC’s closure

TO many, the closure of the state-owned utility stores highlights the failure of successive governments to reform...
Going nowhere
02 Aug, 2025

Going nowhere

THE Sukkur-Hyderabad Motorway seems to be paved with broken promises and not much else. No matter how many times the...
一天当中什么时候最热 耳朵背后有痣代表什么 电器发生火灾用什么灭火器 大小脸去医院挂什么科 山楂和什么一起泡水喝
什么是有机食品和无机食品 黄芪和北芪有什么区别 甲亢吃什么药好得快 黑马什么意思 豇豆不能和什么一起吃
尿酸高吃什么药最好 印刷厂主要做什么 生吃大蒜有什么好处和坏处 怕热是什么体质 湿疹用什么药膏最有效
阿修罗是什么意思 为什么会得阴道炎 什么是公历 硬卧代硬座是什么意思 肝气不舒有什么症状
心病科主要看什么病hcv9jop5ns3r.cn 蚊虫叮咬涂什么药cl108k.com 目敢念什么hcv8jop4ns0r.cn 夸加包念什么xianpinbao.com 三轮体空是什么意思hcv7jop6ns1r.cn
尽形寿是什么意思hcv9jop0ns8r.cn 大脑缺氧有什么症状hcv8jop0ns0r.cn 酸菜鱼什么鱼最好hcv9jop1ns8r.cn 11月份生日是什么星座hcv9jop3ns6r.cn 一个六一个允念什么zhiyanzhang.com
痛风不能吃什么xjhesheng.com asia是什么意思hcv7jop9ns6r.cn 直是什么意思hcv8jop3ns1r.cn 打喷嚏流鼻涕吃什么药hcv8jop9ns5r.cn 吃什么对肠胃好hcv8jop0ns8r.cn
化胡为佛是什么意思hcv8jop3ns7r.cn 胎芽是什么意思hcv8jop8ns9r.cn 艳阳高照是什么生肖hcv9jop3ns4r.cn 什么药可以帮助睡眠hcv8jop4ns9r.cn 中华草龟吃什么hcv9jop5ns1r.cn
百度